Start a Duel

Free tools

Sample Comparison Scorecard

Got samples from several Chinese suppliers? Score them on the same criteria and see which one really wins, not just the cheapest. Scores 1–10, 10 is best.

Supplier A
Supplier B
Supplier C
+ Supplier D
+ Supplier E

Example: these are made-up numbers to show how it works. Enter your own samples above.

Supplier C leads with 81/100
1. Supplier C81
2. Supplier A73
3. Supplier B72
Criterion (weight)Supplier ASupplier BSupplier C
Unit price (20%)8.6
$4.2
10
$3.6
7.5
$4.8
MOQ (10%)3
1,000 pcs
6
500 pcs
10
300 pcs
Lead time (10%)8.3
30 days
10
25 days
7.1
35 days
Workmanship (15%)759
Materials (15%)869
Matches spec (10%)768
Packaging (5%)678
Communication (5%)796
Supplier trust (10%)857
Supplier typeReal factoryTrading companyNot checked
Total / 100737281

Supplier B, Supplier C are not confirmed as a real factory. Check one supplier for free →

How to score samples fairly

  1. Unbox all samples at the same time and photograph them on the same background.
  2. Measure each one against your spec sheet, not against each other.
  3. Choose the weighting before you look at prices, so the cheapest sample does not win by default.
  4. Check who you are dealing with: a trading company is not a problem, but you should know it before you compare lead times and prices.
Duel Box 3

Each supplier normally ships its sample separately, and you pay international shipping every time on top of $80.00 in sample fees. A Duel Box collects samples from 3 or 5 factories in China, ships them in one box and gives you this comparison done for you, with photos, measurements and a factory check.

See Duel Box 3

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare samples from different Chinese suppliers?

Put all samples side by side under the same light, measure them against the same spec and score each on the same criteria: workmanship, materials, how well it matches your spec, packaging, plus price, MOQ and lead time. Decide the weights before you look, so the cheapest sample does not win by default.

How are price, MOQ and lead time scored?

Relative to the best offer: the lowest price, lowest MOQ and shortest lead time get 10 points, and the others get 10 x best / theirs. A supplier 25% more expensive than the cheapest scores 8 on price.

What if I did not fill in a criterion for every supplier?

That criterion is left out for everyone, and the remaining weights are scaled up to 100, so no supplier is penalised for a blank field.

Related: MOQ cash flow simulator · Sample Duel Box report · How to compare supplier samples side by side · Landed cost calculator

Free · 24 hours

Is your supplier a real factory or a trading company?

Send one Alibaba link or company name. We check the business license, ownership and risk records and email you the answer within 24 hours.